From Midfield General to Bench Warmer
Just a few seasons ago, Ismael Bennacer stood as one of AC Milan’s most reliable midfielders. His composure, vision, and tackling made him an essential cog in Stefano Pioli’s system. However, the Algerian international now finds himself marginalized at San Siro. Injuries, tactical changes, and new arrivals have pushed him down the pecking order.
As frustration grows, rumors now link Bennacer with a sensational switch to Juventus, Milan’s historic rivals. The possibility of such a move has shocked Rossoneri supporters and fueled heated debates across Italy.
Bennacer’s Decline in Milan’s Hierarchy
Bennacer arrived at Milan from Empoli in 2019 and quickly earned trust with commanding midfield displays. He played a vital role in Milan’s 2021/22 Serie A title-winning campaign, breaking up play and launching attacks from deep.
Yet, injuries disrupted his rhythm. A serious knee problem sidelined him during a crucial stretch. In his absence, Milan adjusted tactics and integrated new midfield signings like Tijjani Reijnders and Ruben Loftus-Cheek. Consequently, Bennacer returned to find fewer opportunities awaiting him.
Fonseca’s Tactical Choices
New coach Paulo Fonseca favors a dynamic midfield trio built around physicality and vertical movement. Bennacer’s style, though elegant, does not fully align with Fonseca’s aggressive pressing and transition demands.
Instead, Fonseca relies heavily on Reijnders’ energy and Loftus-Cheek’s box-to-box presence. This tactical evolution has left Bennacer struggling to regain his old role. His appearances often come as a substitute rather than a starter.
Juventus Monitoring Closely
Juventus sense an opportunity. The Bianconeri aim to rebuild their midfield under new coach Thiago Motta. They seek technical players who can control possession and dictate tempo. Bennacer fits this profile perfectly.
Reports from Turin suggest Juventus executives already inquired about Bennacer’s availability. They believe his situation at Milan creates a realistic opening for negotiations. Additionally, Bennacer’s contract runs until 2027, but Milan may consider selling if a significant bid arrives.
A Controversial Possibility
For Milan fans, the idea of Bennacer joining Juventus feels like betrayal. Rivalries between the clubs run deep, and switching sides always sparks controversy. Historically, transfers between Milan and Juventus often left scars, such as Andrea Pirlo’s shocking move in 2011.
If Bennacer follows a similar path, he risks tarnishing his legacy with Milan supporters who once idolized him. However, from a professional standpoint, Juventus could offer him a fresh start and regular minutes.
Juventus’ Midfield Plans
Juventus currently rely on Manuel Locatelli, Adrien Rabiot, and Nicolò Fagioli. However, they want another midfielder capable of controlling tempo under pressure. Bennacer’s technical qualities, press resistance, and defensive awareness make him a natural fit.
Thiago Motta values midfielders who combine intelligence with work rate. Bennacer’s experience in Serie A and Champions League gives him an advantage over less proven targets.
Milan’s Dilemma
Milan face a difficult choice. Keeping Bennacer means retaining depth and experience, but selling could free up funds for reinforcements. With ongoing concerns about financial balance, the Rossoneri may accept a lucrative offer from Juventus despite fan backlash.
Reports suggest Milan want at least €40 million to part with Bennacer. Whether Juventus meet that demand remains uncertain, but negotiations could intensify as the January transfer window approaches.
Fans React Strongly
Unsurprisingly, speculation about Bennacer’s future has triggered intense reactions. Milan fans flooded social media with pleas to keep him. Many argued his experience remains vital, especially in big matches.
Juventus fans, however, welcomed the rumors. They view Bennacer as a potential upgrade who could bring stability and balance to their midfield. The contrast in reactions highlights the polarizing nature of the potential transfer.
Bennacer’s Perspective
So far, Bennacer has remained professional and avoided public statements. However, sources close to him claim he feels frustrated with limited playing time. At 26, he knows these are peak years for a midfielder.
If Milan cannot guarantee him a starting role, Bennacer may seek opportunities elsewhere. Juventus, offering a central role under Motta, could become an attractive option.
Possible Outcomes
Several scenarios remain possible:
- Bennacer stays at Milan and fights to reclaim his spot.
- Juventus submit a formal bid, forcing Milan to decide between finances and loyalty.
- Foreign clubs intervene, as Premier League sides also monitor his situation.
- A late compromise sees Milan keep Bennacer until summer before reassessing.
Regardless, his future looks increasingly uncertain as Juventus circle.
Conclusion: A Decision That Could Redefine Careers
Ismael Bennacer’s story highlights the unpredictable nature of football careers. From midfield general to bench option, his decline at Milan surprised many. Now, with Juventus showing interest, his next step could redefine both his career and legacy.
For Milan, selling to their fiercest rival could spark outrage but also provide financial relief. For Juventus, signing Bennacer could complete their midfield puzzle. For the player, the choice rests between loyalty and opportunity.
One thing is clear: the saga of Bennacer’s future promises to dominate Italian football headlines in the coming months.
Read too: Ignored by Ruben Amorim, Kobbie Mainoo Now on the Radar of Real Madrid and Atletico Madrid
